The subject of tax reform is getting more and more discussion in Washington, D.C. and across the country as taxpayers grow increasingly frustrated with the complexity of our income tax system. The conventional wisdom is that it is unlikely that anything will happen with tax reform in 2014 because it is an election year. However, after the new Congress is seated in 2015, tax reform could receive some serious attention.
In February, the Ways and Means Committee, chaired by Congressman Camp, released its discussion draft of the “Tax Reform Act of 2014”. The discussion draft proposes a sweeping overhaul of the individual and business income tax system. It proposes the elimination of a number of tax deductions, tax credits and business tax breaks, while calling for the reduction of the top individual tax rate from 39.6 percent to 35 percent along with a reduction in the top corporate tax rates for 35 percent to 25 percent.
A number of favorable tax provisions for the real estate industry are targeted for reduction or elimination by the discussion draft. They include:
Mortgage Interest Deduction
The discussion draft would allow taxpayers to continue to claim an itemized deduction for mortgage interest on mortgage debt used to acquire the taxpayer’s residence. However, the $1 million limitation on qualifying debt would be reduced to $500,000. In addition, the deduction for interest on home equity debt would be eliminated.
Determination of Self-Employment (SE) Income
The discussion draft proposes that the self-employment tax would be applicable to income from S corporations where the shareholders or partners materially participate in the business. The SE tax would also be applied to all general and limited partners of partnerships, including limited liability companies under the same material participation standard. In calculating self-employment income for both partners and S corporation shareholders, a new deduction would be allowed to approximate the income earned on invested capital. This deduction would be equal to 30 percent of the income passed through from the partnership or S corporation. Passive investors (no material participation) in partnerships and S corporation would not be subject to the SE tax on any of the income.
Overhaul of the Accelerated Cost Recovery System (ACRS)
The discussion draft proposes a major overhaul of the ACRS system. First year bonus depreciation would be eliminated and ACRS depreciation lives would generally be lengthened. The special 15 year depreciation provisions for qualified leasehold improvement property, qualified restaurant property, and qualified retail improvement property would also be eliminated.
Section 179 expensing would be made permanent at the $250,000 level with a phase-out of the deduction starting at $800,000 of new investments. Investments in heating and air conditioning units would qualify for section 179 expensing under the discussion draft.
Domestic Production Activity Deduction
The discussion draft proposes the elimination of the deduction for income from domestic production activities. This deduction currently applies to real estate construction activities.
Section 1031 Like-Kind Exchanges
The special rule allowing deferral of gain on like-kind exchanges of real estate under current Internal Revenue Code Section 1031 would be repealed under the provisions of the discussion draft.
Repeal of Rehabilitation Tax Credit
The provisions of the discussion draft propose to repeal entirely the tax credit allowed under current law for expenses incurred to rehabilitate old and/or historic buildings.
The discussion draft has many other provisions that could impact the real estate and construction industry. The Low Income Housing Tax Credit would be retained under the provisions of the discussion draft, but substantial modifications would be made to its provisions.
The installment sale rules would be modified under the discussion draft so that the current interest charge rules on the gain deferred by an installment sale would apply to any installment sale in excess of $150,000. Under current law, the interest charge rules only apply to installment sales in excess of $5 million.
All depreciation taken on real estate after enactment of the tax reform proposals would be taxed as ordinary income upon the sale of the real estate. Under current law this ordinary income treatment only applies to the excess of accelerated depreciation over straight line depreciation.
Finally, the discussion drafts proposes a number of substantial changes to the tax provisions applicable to REITs. The major thrust of these provisions is aimed at preventing operating businesses that are taxable as C corporations from converting to REIT status. However, under the provisions of the discussion draft related to REIT’s the definition of “real property” under the REIT definition/classification rules would exclude real property with a class life less than 27.5 years and would exclude Timber from the definition of “real property”.
While the U.S. system of income taxation is in need of simplification, it remains to be seen which of the provisions of the Ways and Means discussion draft will ultimately be adopted. We will need to wait and see for what promises to be a very lively and heated debate when Congress finally does take on the overhaul of our income tax system.
L. Michael Gracik, Jr., CPA is the Managing Partner of Keiter, P.C. in Richmond, Virginia. He has over 37 years of experience and tax insights. His clients include closely held businesses in the real estate, home building, manufacturing, and construction industries. He can be reached at email@example.com.
This article was republished with permission from National Real Estate Investor.